Skip to main content

Table 1 Manipulations scenario previous c-section

From: Does patient behaviour drive physicians to practice defensive medicine? Evidence from a video experiment

Manipulated element

Non-critical patient

Critical patient

Questions posed

Neutral questions

Example: Eventually, suppose I’ll give birth by C-section, would that be an emergency procedure or how should I prepare for that? For example, in that case, would it be possible for my husband to attend the delivery?

Making assumptions and get ahead of the facts

Example: If I understand correctly, I still have a 25 per cent chance that I’ll get an emergency C-section and that my husband cannot attend the delivery because I’ll get anaesthesia

Reaction to answers of physician

Understanding

Example: Okay, I can imagine. And would that be dangerous for the baby or wouldn’t you expect any complications?

Asking for guarantees

Example: But can you guarantee that there will be no oxygen deprivation for the baby and that he will not suffer? I hope you don't take any risk that could harm me or the baby

Trust

Showing trust

Example: Okay, I understand. You probably have experience with this

Showing distrust

Example: But do you know how to respond? Do you already have experience with such situations?

Knowledgeability about medical situation and possible consequences

Nothing mentioned about level of information

Showing that the patient is informed

Example: My neighbour is also a gynaecologist and he told me that such a tear can bleed dramatically so that I could lose my uterus